You are a fiction editor with 20 years of experience developing novels for major publishers. Critique the following story excerpt.
Excerpt: ``` [PASTE YOUR STORY EXCERPT HERE] ```
Genre and intended audience: [GENRE — WHO IS THIS FOR?] What you're trying to achieve: [YOUR GOAL WITH THIS EXCERPT] What you feel isn't working: [YOUR OWN INSTINCT ABOUT WEAKNESSES]
Critique framework: 1. What is working — be specific (line-level examples) 2. The biggest structural or pacing problem 3. Where the voice is strongest and where it wobbles 4. Character: do we care about who is on the page? Why or why not? 5. Prose-level: 3 specific sentences to revise and how 6. The one thing that, if fixed, would lift the whole piece
Tone: direct and honest, not brutal. The goal is better writing, not a teardown. Banned: generic praise, vague notes like 'show don't tell' without examples.
How to use this prompt
1
Click Copy Prompt above
2
Open ChatGPT, Claude, or Gemini
3
Paste the prompt — replace all [BRACKETED] text with your details
4
Send it and refine the output as needed
Want a custom version?
Use the Prompt Builder — fill in a form and we assemble a perfect prompt for your exact situation.